Monthly Archives: June 2010

Missions of the Reliant: Why having two coordinate spaces is a problem.

The best laid schemes o’ mice an’ men / Gang aft agley
– Robert Burns, “To a Mouse, on Turning Her Up in Her Nest, with the Plough”

The torpedos do work, there’s no doubt about that. There’s just one problem: Due to the fact that velocity in my code is expressed in terms of the game’s galaxy coordinate space rather than screen coordinate space as Mike’s code did, my torpedos have different physics than his.

In the original Missions, a torpedo once fired would have the same visual velocity no matter how the player’s direction and velocity changed. For example, a torpedo would take the same length of time to go off screen whether the player continued at full speed or hit full stop immediately after firing.

In my port, a torpedo obeys more traditional physics: If you fire a torpedo from full speed and then hit full stop immediately, it will zoom off the screen at twice the apparent velocity. If you fire from a full stop and immediately accelerate to full speed, you’ll practically run the torpedo over (though they move fast enough that one can not in fact actually do so).

Implementing the old behavior essentially means installing a velocity listener on the player and adjusting the torpedo’s absolute velocity as the player’s delta-V changes. This change, implemented more sweepingly, would bring back an interesting behavior of the old game. Try launching Missions in SheepShaver and holding down forward thrust and left turn immediately; the starbase sprite will move out of position relative to the player ship.

The old behavior is almost certainly not preferable for starbases and planets and enemies. But it certainly made aiming torpedos a bit easier, based on a bit of testing I’ve done versus the working fighters. Even the AI of the fighters has an easier time hitting me with “stable-velocity” torpedos than it does with realistic physics.

I’m at a bit of a loss for which way to go with this. I’ll continue onto implementing other things, as coming back to this issue is always possible.

Missions of the Reliant: Belay that phaser order! Arm photon torpedos!

Torpedos now work.

There are some minor glitches, mainly that it should only take two torpedos to destroy a fighter on easy difficulty, not six, but that’s the only remaining issue with the torpedos themselves. I already know the cause (the damage factor is randomized twice, which produces completely wrong numbers) and I’ll fix it next.

I’d like to apologize for taking so long to get done with what may seem like a simple thing. There were two major issues that made torpedos so difficult:

  1. There was an underlying graphical error across the entire game that had gone more or less unnoticed until now because torpedos were the first sprites to be severely affected by it. It seemed that OpenGL was doing linear filtering on textures when scaling them to the power-of-two rectangles per GL_TEXTURE_RECTANGLE_ARB instead of nearest neighbor. Problem: I was calling glTexParameteri(GL_TEXTURE_RECTANGLE_ARB, GL_TEXTURE_MIN_FILTER, GL_NEAREST), ditto for GL_TEXTURE_MAG_FILTER. Why wasn’t this working? I tried a long list of solutions, including subpixel offset (glTranslated(0.375, 0.375, 0.0)), switching to ARB_non_power_of_two (which failed completely for reasons I still don’t understand), and texture padding. Finally, it dawned on a friend that I was calling glTexParameteri() only once, in -prepareOpenGL, instead of each time I did a glBindTexture(). The assumption was that texture parameters worked the same as the rest of OpenGL, such that state is sticky once set. Fail. Setting the parameters before each glTexImage2D() fixed the problem. That was a fun week of frustration.
  2. I had not, until now, implemented collision detection. If you look carefully at Missions, you find that collision detection is actually only necessary in exactly two places:
    1. Torpedos (including standard player and enemy torpedos, antimatter torpedos, and the planet-busters fired by the battleship).
    2. Missiles (as fired by defense satellites)
    It took some time to implement collision detection, partly because I’d made some bad design decisions in the code much earlier on that had to be fixed to make it work in any reasonable way.

With torpedos working, we’re on the home stretch. Almost everything else is assembling components that already exist in the code. Stay tuned for further updates!

Tic-Tacs

With apologies to Pete Seeger and Malvina Reynolds…

Little Tic-Tacs in the boxes
Little Tic-Tacs made of sugar gum
Little Tic-Tacs, little Tic-Tacs, little Tic-Tacs all the same
There’s a white one, and a white one, and a white one, and a white one
And they’re all made out of Ticky-Tacky
And they all look just the same

This came to me when someone said “Tic-Tacs” and “ticky-tacky” to me. That is all.